This is a difficult evening to write up. This new play by Alice Birch is dealing with a very important topic but was - for me- overcomplex in its structure. It all started fine with two women talking about the new boyfriend of one of them. Then the next scene had a young addict breaking into her own house to steal some money. Then I started to get lost. Each of the subsequent scenes (picked from the 100 scenes available in the text) worked well or very well in its own right - and particularly the scenes with the two excellent child actors but piecing it all together in a way that I could truly recount what happened is beyond me. People got sent to prison; tried to commit suicide; had a baby. But then there was a scene at a dinner party where mushy liberal-views-spouting women were taken down by the new girlfriend of one of them - questioning for example whether #metoo was really of global significance. This was interesting and maybe was a counterpoint to us being bothered about women in prison in the first place. But then, one of the children came and smashed the table up.
In the end, I was left feeling inadequate for not following this complex piece but in truth the criticism probably lies with the play and its directors who insufficiently grasped how baffling the whole thing would be for an unprepared audience seeing it for the first time. Apart from dipping in to the 100 scenes, Birch apparently doesn't give the characters names in the text but just letters. That would explain how we ended up with the same actors (in the same clothes) playing different characters.
It was a two hour straight run and not surprisingly a few people sneaked out. Most stayed and the acting got some whoops of applause. That was deserved, as was the rendition of the individual scenes. The problem was tying it all together. A failure on that front, apart from anything else, surely means the message is somewhat lost on the viewer. This is a pity as the joint production by the Donmar and Clean Break clearly has an important message to convey - especially in the era of Priti Patel as Home Secretary.
No comments:
Post a Comment